Thomas Germain said he fooled three AI systems with one blog post. The Tech Report hosted the BBC journalist to walk through the test, which hit Google AI Overviews, Gemini and ChatGPT through a remote public post with no privileged access.
Before AI Overviews, SEO spam left Google serving 300 identical product pages, Germain said. Then AI Overviews started pulling that same web directly into answers.
Germain said, "I was the world champion tech journalist hot dog eater that I'd won some contest that I made up." Within 24 hours the three systems cited the fiction as fact, often without naming his site, Germain said. He argued the difference between AEO and SEO work is minimal, so AEO vs SEO compared to old SEO pitches is the same optimization sold twice.
Traditional SEO still means relevance, site structure, backlinks and technical performance, per Searchable. That definition matters because no separate pricing or feature set makes one better. Germain said buyers get the same web either way.
Banks and Amazon have blocked external agents on their platforms, the host noted. The Air Canada bereavement case remains the clear precedent, with a court holding the airline to a refund invented by its chatbot. Germain asked who pays when an agent spends $10,000 unasked, the provider or the user.
Germany found Google liable for AI Overview inaccuracies, Germain said. In the United States a talk show host lost a similar claim against OpenAI on narrow grounds. Anthropic now lets Claude end abusive chats over possible consciousness concerns, while Character AI settled a wrongful death suit without precedent. No court has set a date for the agent-spending case Germain expects.




