University library systems are buckling under remote, high-volume AI scraping that needs no login, only endless complex queries. CTV News reported new University of Edinburgh research on rising costs and lost access, with Peter Lewis, Canada Research Chair in Trustworthy Artificial Intelligence at Ontario Tech University, saying the load can mimic a denial of service attack.
The obvious reading is that greedy labs are looting public knowledge. I am not convinced the villain story explains the failure, because no one has shown who runs most of the bots.
Lewis said one library logged more than two million bot queries in four weeks linked to firms including Apple, OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, Tencent and Meta. He cited more than 11,000 searches in a single day in 2024 for niche music holdings at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Library. The fair concession is that libraries run lean systems built for students, not industrial harvest, so heavy queries can knock human users offline.
Attribution still stops at brand names on traffic logs.
In October, Lewis said OpenAI, Google, Microsoft and Anthropic agreed to respect a policy token for training opt-out, a voluntary industry fix. Lewis argued four volunteers do not make a rule when labs are racing for higher quality data and niche expertise, the two drivers he said are pushing crawlers toward libraries, archives and museums. His preferred fix is platform charging agreements that set load and payment up front, with per-query micro-charges as a weaker technical cousin.
CP24 separately described the incidents as outages at university library websites, a harder failure than slow service. If you want library data, negotiate load and payment before you crawl, because free riding at this scale reads as an attack.




